How much to discount for no basement? - Posted by Perron

answer - Posted by comps

Posted by comps on June 21, 2005 at 15:01:15:

I asked that question of you to make a point. Since you didn’t answer, I will:

If you are only referring to appraisers calling the square footage of a house as being the square footage listed in the above ground category of the appraisal, I would agree with you. However, it is wrong to generally state that appraisers don’t count or calculate the value of below ground areas (which was the original claim here). It is important for investors to know the difference.

The POINT of an appraisal is to VALUE the house. Banks, buyers, sellers, tax assessors, insurance companies, etc. plus investors all pay primary attention to the appraised VALUE of a house, not what the appraisers consider as the official square footage of a house.

An appraiser can claim all day long that a house has only 1200 sq ft but when everybody else (including the appraiser) values all finished 2400 sq ft (1200 above, 1200 below), his claim becomes rather moot and becomes pretty much a professional quirk. The MLS, the assessor, etc. all call the house as having 2400 sq ft. In real life we are concerned with the true VALUE and properly finished square footage is “counted” and calculated into the value, whether it be above ground or below ground.

You CAN say appraisers “don’t count” below grade.
(in the sense that they only consider above grade to count toward the official square footage of a house)

You CAN’T say appraisers “don’t count” below grade.
(in the sense that they don’t count finished below grade square footage toward value - because they do!)

Hope this clarifies things.

appraiser count value but NOT sqft below grade - Posted by David Krulac

Posted by David Krulac on June 22, 2005 at 10:27:21:

in a previous post you said they add it to sqft. That’s not true. A finished basement will add value, but not sqft. Below grade footage adds ZERO to the sqft of a house. A 2 story house with 2400 sqft is not comped by a bilevel house with 1200 sqft per floor with one floor being below grade. The bilevel house will probably be listed in the assessors roll as 2400 sqft and maybe even in the MLS as 2400 sqft, but when appraised will be listed as 1200 sqft with a finished lower level, which adds value, but not at the same price per sqft as the above grade sqft. If you are uncertain look at some appraisal courses, take some appraisal course or talk to an appraiser.

Re: appraiser count value - Posted by Mrs. Forrest

Posted by Mrs. Forrest on March 24, 2006 at 14:50:40:

How much value DOES an unfinished basement add to a house?